SA is not one nation but many

ImageYonatan Fessha’s opinion piece reminds me a bit of the story about the emperor’s new clothes, SA’s mazy route through the province of ethnicity.
 
Since 1994 at least, but going back to the 1950s when the South African Communist Party rejected the notion (against the advice of the Soviet Academy of Sciences) that SA contained more than one nation, it has been almost an academic and political truism that there is such a thing as one, undivided South African nation with a common culture, language and identity.

According to this view — held by political scientists from the University of Potchefstroom to the University of Cape Town, as well as all parties in Parliament except perhaps the Freedom Front Plus — the difference in being an Afrikaner and a Xhosa is of the same order as choosing tagliatelle or penne for pasta bolognaise.

The language issue has since been comfortably solved by the equally universal adoption of English and, as one informed academic recently put it to me, “the virtual collapse of the Pan South African Languages Board”. But we are also familiar with the argument that Afrikaans was an invention of the National Party and the other nine languages the pernicious creations of missionary grammarians out to divide “the nation”.

Fessha’s notion that ethnicity is of such little consequence that provinces may be parcelled out along linguistic lines without affecting our common, green-blooded, flag-waving patriotism, will no doubt be welcomed by Afrikaners who have long called for a 10th province.

Of course, as a chorus of professors and politicians would assure us, the torture and extreme violence that have become characteristic of our national conduct toward fellow patriots are not indicative of any ethnic friction, but merely an indication of the ingenuity of our common-law criminals who tend not just to steal a cellphone, but spend a further eight hours to ensure the former owner will never again have any use for it.

Also published as a letter in Business Day on 11 December 2007.

free bonus slotФильчаков прокурор

Maak 'n opvolg-bydrae